Total Depravity with Matt Slick, Part 1

The Doctrine of “Total Inability” in Calvinism

In a recent discussion on Calvinism, the focus was on the doctrine of “Total Inability,” a key tenet of the TULIP acronym. This doctrine suggests that due to the original sin of Adam and Eve, humans are inherently incapable of seeking God or doing good without divine intervention. The conversation highlighted several biblical passages, questioning the Calvinist interpretation that humans are born in a state of total spiritual depravity.

The discussion pointed out that while humans are indeed sinful, the Bible does not explicitly support the idea that we are utterly incapable of responding to God. For instance, scriptures like Deuteronomy 30:19 and Joshua 24:15 present choices to the people, implying an ability to choose God. Additionally, the notion of “Total Inability” seems to conflict with the biblical portrayal of God’s love, which is described as unfailing and all-encompassing.

Critics argue that the Calvinist view makes the gospel an unreasonable demand, as it commands repentance from those supposedly unable to respond. The conversation also questioned the assumption that Adam was created morally perfect, suggesting instead that he was created with original innocence, not moral perfection.

Ultimately, the discussion called for a reevaluation of the doctrine of “Total Inability,” urging a return to a biblical understanding that emphasizes personal responsibility, the freedom to choose, and the boundless love of God.